• Menu

    What’s it going to be then, eh?

    The International Anthony Burgess Foundation
    About Anthony Burgess
    • Introducing Anthony Burgess
    • The Books of Anthony Burgess
    • The Music of Anthony Burgess
    Discover More
    • A Clockwork Orange
    • Earthly Powers
    • Anthony Burgess and Shakespeare
    • Dystopian Fiction
    About The Foundation
    • Our Mission
    • Visiting Us
    • The Burgess Bar
    • Support the Burgess Foundation
    • Join our mailing list
    • Contact us
    Anthony Burgess Archive
    • About the Archive
    • Visiting the Archive
    • Object of the Week
    • Contact the Archivist
    What's On
    • News and Blogs
    • Event listings
    • Venue hire
    • Burgess Prize
    • Exhibitions
    • Podcasts
    The International Anthony Burgess Foundation
  • What’s it going to be then, eh?

    OPENING TIMES
    Bar Open for events
    Reading Room Available for pre-booked appointments 10.00am - 3.00pm weekdays
    Office Hours By appointment: info@anthonyburgess.org
    HOW TO FIND US
    Engine House
    Chorlton Mill
    3 Cambridge Street
    Manchester
    M1 5BY
    Nearest train station Oxford Road More information
    Next event
    Literature: Poets & Players Sat 25 Mar 2023 2:30 pm Free More information
  • The International Anthony Burgess Foundation
  • What's it going to be then, eh?

    Exhibitions. New writing. Concert commissions. Academic research. Public events, in venues and online. And at the core of everything, preserving and promoting our extensive Anthony Burgess archive.

    Your donation to the Burgess Foundation supports our mission to promote the life and work of Anthony Burgess in so many ways.

  • What’s it going to be then, eh?

The International Anthony Burgess Foundation The International Anthony Burgess Foundation
NEWS AND BLOG POSTS

Object of the Week: Burgess’s Copy of Dune

  • Graham Foster

  • 6th June 2017
  • category

  • Object of the Week
  • tagged as

  • 1985
  • A Clockwork Orange
  • Archive
  • Brian Aldiss
  • Burgess 100
  • Collections
  • dystopia
  • Frank Herbert
  • J.G. Ballard
  • Object of the Week
  • Science Fiction
  • The End Of The World News
  • The Wanting Seed

This copy of Frank Herbert’s Dune dates from 1966, when Anthony Burgess reviewed it for the Observer. He was impressed by the scope of the book and by the calibre of Herbert’s literary creation. The review displays a wide knowledge of science-fiction conventions.

Dune is set on Arrakis, a desert planet on which humans mine a mind-expanding spice called ‘melange’. Arrakis is home to giant sandworms, a native species which creates the spice as a by-product of their life-cycle. Arrakis is also troubled by a long feud between aristocratic families. It is in this setting that Herbert’s novel describes the rise of Paul Atreides, the heir to the House of Atreides, who has superhuman powers and is an expert military strategist.

In his review of Dune, Burgess writes: ‘The Duke of Atreides and Baron Harkonnen and the rest of them are genuine characters whose acts emotionally involve the reader’. Even so, the review is not completely complimentary. Burgess adds: ‘this devotion to detail and the evidence of immense literary care tend less to exalt the spirit than to depress it. What a waste, really. All this skill expended on mere fantasy’.

Elsewhere in his round-up review of new science fiction, Burgess is vocal about his dislike of the genre, claiming that ‘SF,’ as he calls it, is not written by artists, but by ‘a laboratory-man chain-smoking over a weekend typewriter.’ Of the cerebral value of science fiction, Burgess writes: ‘it resembles Jane Austen in its intellectual engagement. But Jane Austen at least created amiable characters and wrote very well’.

Elsewhere in his journalism, Burgess expanded on his reasons for disliking science fiction, claiming that it was often dull and poorly written. ‘You practice the genre if you have fancy but no imagination. Bizarre things matter more than such fictional staples as character, psychological probability and credible dialogue. There is usually an atmosphere of evasion of real-life issues, occasionally qualified by dutiful lip-service shibboleths about human freedom and embattled ecology. Content counts more than form.’

Despite these complaints, there is much evidence that Burgess read widely in the genre, and was, on occasion, willing to be impressed. In Ninety-Nine Novels: The Best in English Since 1939, Burgess selects novels by Brian Aldiss (a friend from the 1960s), J.G. Ballard, Russell Hoban, and L.P. Hartley (for his little-known novel, Facial Justice). He also identifies lesser-known works of speculative fiction, including Pavane by Keith Roberts, an counter-factual historical novel which portrays Catholic Britain in rebellion against the dominance of the Church. The book collection at the Burgess Foundation contains many other works of science fiction, including novels by H.G.Wells, Aldous Huxley, W.J. Burley and Margaret Atwood.

Although Burgess occasionally said disobliging things about genre fiction in his journalism, it is clear from his own novels that he thought writing science fiction was worthwhile. A Clockwork Orange, presents a dystopian world in which violent droogs rampage through urban streets, and The Wanting Seed shows a future Britain turned into a megalopolis by over-population. In The End of the World News Burgess tries his hand at apocalyptic fiction, and 1985 is a work of speculative fiction, written in response to George Orwell.

Burgess’s love of literature transcended generic boundaries, and his occasional denigration of science fiction does not tell the whole story about his lifelong engagement with the genre. His work as a critic often reveals surprises, and it shows that he was able to judge books on their merits, and not according to preconceptions about genre. Dune is a useful example. While it appears, on the surface, to be a novel at variance with Burgess’s interests, he is impressed, perhaps reluctantly, by Herbert’s sheer ability as a writer.

Read on: See the full series of Objects Of The Week >

  • Share | 
  • Print
Related Blog posts
A Shorter Finnegans Wake: editing an epic Andrew Biswell
Inside the archive: Restoring Joyce and Belli Anna Edwards
Blowing the horn for Anthony Burgess in 2023 Andrew Biswell
The 2023 Observer / Burgess Prize has a winner Ian Carrington
SEE ALL NEWS AND BLOG POSTS
Go to home page
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Go to home page
Follow us

© 2023 International Anthony Burgess Foundation

Charity no. 1102623

International Anthony Burgess Foundation
Engine House Chorlton Mill 3 Cambridge Street M1 5BY
  • Site map
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms of use
  • Designed by Instruct
  • Built by OH Digital